Journal article review. sourcing and analysing ir information Essay Example

  • Category:
  • Document type:
  • Level:
  • Page:
  • Words:

Journal Article Review: Sourcing and Analyzing Industrial Relations Information

Journal Article Review: Sourcing and Analyzing Industrial Relations Information

The journal article under review is from the British Journal of Industrial Relations volume 46, issue number 2 of June 2008, in pages 248-267. The title Union Mobilization: A Consideration of the Factors Affecting the Willingness of Union Members to Take Industrial Action, is an apparent and direct representation of the content of the entire article. The authors, Donna M. Buttigieg, Stephen J. Deery and Roderick D. Iverson capture the complete fundamental nature of the article in the title.

The abstract summarizes the key findings and arguments that have been presented in the article. Major arguments are outlined like the mobilization theory which is the foundation of the article’s perspective. In addition, the findings that are most influential to the paper’s thesis are summarized. The abstract identifies that workers are most likely to take industrial action if they experience unfairness or injustice, if they hold a collectivist direction and if the representation that they have at with the union is influential.

Other than that, the article’s research nature is summarized in the abstract where the methodology of the study used to come up with the findings is outlined mentioning the N=1,111 large scale survey done on a union for financial services during a renegotiation for a collective bargaining contract. A complete summary of the major contentions of the article are encompassed in the abstract.

The hypotheses that are contained in the article as well as the findings and conclusions are arrived at and supported by drawing on data from a large scale survey. This makes it a piece that is based on empirical-research data. Research methods that were used have been explained adequately. The major players of the organization and union that inspired the study have been identified as a financial services union and a large multinational banking organization; both of whom are located in Australia. The issue is the renegotiation of a collective bargaining contract. Details that are contained in the context help to explain reasons for the choices made in the methodology as well as its appropriateness for the study.

With the context of the issue providing a foundation for the methodology, the approaches that were used are described in detail. The people who were involved on interview are specifically identified as elected officials, union employees and union representatives. The systematic narrowing down of the sample size is described with reasons for excluding and including the individuals utilized as the sample is explained with reference to the aim of the study.

The surveys that were carried out are explained in terms of duration, numbers, percentages and rationales for exclusion and inclusion. For instance, from the surveys that were returned, the choice made was to make use of surveys that were from union members because the study was concerned with issues that involved mobilizing union members. In addition, details of the measurement tools and information are elucidated and justified. For instance, a description of the questionnaires that contained Likert-type scales and some of the questions presented, give the reader a picture of the study that was undertaken. The methodology also illustrates how reliability was tested and the results achieved.

Though the article has a detailed quality to its advantage as well as a coherent trait, it could be made better by using relational analysis to make its arguments stronger. Studies on the same subject with less definitive results could be mentioned since they will give the article’s key arguments more competencies. Additionally, since the article draws its line of reasoning from the mobilization theory, more details about the theory would aid in understanding the argument being presented. Information about the origins of the theory and its basic tenets would help the reader understand why it was chosen for the topic.

In addition, the theory should be related to the contextual foundation of the study. In explaining the context of the study and describing the historical relationship between the union and the banking organization, some analysis should be included to show how the context relates to the hypotheses and theories that have been put across to guide the direction of the article. The attitude of the employees should be analyzed from the perspective of the milieu that was created the banking organization. For instance, the analysis should include how gradual alteration of the organization’s attitude towards the union led to the union deciding on industrial action. The article should also mention the conditions that were in the union to address the issue of representatives better.

The article has enabled me to understand that industrial relations are complex in nature and the parties involved should be based on open communication. In addition, leadership is one of the most vital and influential things in corporate relations. The issue in between the union and the banking organization were brought to light more aggressively with the change of leadership in the union. The leadership on either side should be up to date with the changes that take place in the organization so that they incorporate the union. At the beginning, both sides were getting benefits to their satisfaction. With time, the union saw that the organization was flourishing more while the union remained the same.

By showing the context that brought about the issue between the bank and the union, the article has added to my understanding the fact that mutual benefits need to be felt by all parties that are in an industrial relation for it to work well. It has also come to my attention that some of the specifications that are contained in industrial relations result in neglecting the needs of some parties. Joint management and decision making is an important factor in promoting mutual benefit. The industrial relations should not be taken for granted and the organizations that have entered into such relations with unions should make an effort to ensure that there is a quality to the relations that attracts people to it. The relationship flourished at the beginning because the bank had a better relationship with the union than others.


Buttigieg, DM, Deery,SJ, & Iverson, RD 2008, ‘Union Mobilization: A Consideration of the Factors Affecting the Willingness of Union Members to Take Industrial Action’, British Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 46, no. 2, pp. 248-267.