History — Primary Source Analysis Essay Example

  • Category:
    History
  • Document type:
    Essay
  • Level:
    Undergraduate
  • Page:
    1
  • Words:
    679

Introduction to history- Primary Source Analysis

Week 06 tutorial portfolio assignment

Amélie Kuhrt, The Archaemenid Persian Empire (c.550c.330BCE): Continuities, Adaptations, Transformations, in Empires: Perspectives from Archaeology and History, Susan E. Alcock,  Terence N. D’Altroy, Kathleen D. Morrison and Carla M. Sinopoli,(Cambridge University Press, 2001), pp. 93‐123;

Richard T. Hallock, Selected Fortification Texts, Cahiers de la Délégation Archéologique Française en Iran, no 8, 1978,  accessed 19 January 2011http://www.achemenet.com/document/HALLOCK1978_CDAFI8.pdf .

Secondary Argument 

Primary Source Evidence

Critical comment

Treasury texts produce a fairly clear picture of the urban plan generated by texts celebrating the city; texts are rich with data on delivering mail to the other regions. The texts also constitute an important source of the study of the Old Iranian lexicon.

Bits contained fortification and treasury texts containing personal decrees of Darius I.

A Babylonian named Bel-et Air was assignewd the duty to deliver mails from Susa to Persepolis. (Hallock, 1969, Nos. 1381, 1382), while a different Babylonian was the manager of the noble storehouse (Hallock, 1969, Nos. 81, 489,).

The fortification and treasury tablets have significantly expounded acquaintance of Archaemenid glyptic art. They bear the impersonations of official seals used by royal officials. Persepolis texts comprise a valuable source for the study of the Old Iranian lexicon of Iranian words this helps to reflect the cultural divergence of Persia.

Week 07 tutorial portfolio assignment.

, (National University of Singapore, 2001, Oxford, 2002.)Archaeological ExcavationFlecker,

(Philadelphia: Cappa press) pp 57-74Ingots and Artifacts: when Asia was the worldGordon, S.

Secondary Argument 

Primary Source Evidence

Critical comment

Gordon wrote on the basis memoirs written by indigenous travelers, such as Xuanzang a Chinese

pilgrim who moved within a great Buddhist ecumene, Ibn

Sina an Arab philosopher who corresponded from Persia to Spain, Abraham bin Yiju a Tunisian, founder of the Mughal Empire in India these help to understand the connections between trade and ecumenes.

The diverse cargo that consisted of Chinese goods on board an Indonesian vessel can be regarded as ordinary mainly because Chinese ceramics from the late tang to the Qing Dynasties and widespread throughout the archipelago.

The presence of middle east goods exemplifies the high degree of stylish of the entrepot trade

The historian has used the evidence well to show that the diverse cargo supplying the newly founded eastern capital with the products and raw materials necessary to rebuild the community after the volcanic eruption that perhaps initiated the move

The intan wreck provides a wealth of material to verify, augment or contradict the limited and archeological record.

Week 08 tutorial portfolio assignment.

Jacques Gernet, the city, in daily life in china on the mongal invasion, 1250-1276, H.Wright

(Stanford university press, 1962), pp22-58

Patricia Buckley Ebre, the Attractions of the Capital in Chinese CivilizationA Sourcebook 179‐

85(New York: Free Press, 1993), pp. 178‐85

Secondary Argument 

Primary Source Evidence

Critical comment

Garnet’s take on slavery in Chinese monasteries is worrying for its negligence, which contributes to unreliability of Garnet’s primary sources.  He argued that for Indian Buddhists, Slavery receveid no attention from Buddhist authors thus it there was no problem with slavery.

The primary sources used Oxen, slaves, land, –are just the kinds of property the rules need to be clear about.

Historical evidence used is thin; there is much evidence for the ideology of slavery among Indian Buddhists. Mostly preserved only in its classical translations in Chinese and Tibetan. Explicit treatments of slavery and slaves refer to slavery in Buddhist. Buddhist authors at times refer to themselves as slaves, even possessing such names as Buddhadāsa

Week 09 tutorial portfolio assignment.

Clendinnen, I. fierce and unnatural cruelty: in now world encounters, S. Greenblat (Berkley, CA university of California press, 1993), pp12-23

Corte,H. letters from Mexico, Trans Anthony Padgen (New Haven: Yale university press, 1986), pp 83-87

Secondary Argument 

Primary Source Evidence

Critical comment

Clendinnen looked at the escalating disagreement between rival and increasingly divergent Spanish visions of Yucatan and its negative outcomes. She sought to go through the habits of thinking and reactions of the Mayan Indians in a detailed reconstruction of their appraisal of the intruders with implications for the understanding of European power and local confrontation.

Don Hernan letters to King Charles V is a primary sources, this is because they were written by a Spanish conqueror.

This letter shows the deliberate attempt by Hernan to disobey Diego de Cellar.

Historical evidence show that codices were written by native peoples, however, Spaniards destroyed them in order to eliminate traditional beliefs. 

Itzcoatl, a Mexican King destroyed many manuscripts and there little evidence that production was shaped due to the interaction with Spaniards.