Compare two movies Essay Example

  • Category:
  • Document type:
  • Level:
  • Page:
  • Words:

Comparing Dear White People and Frozen River


Dear White People is an interesting film given it has a critical focus on contemporary issues of the modern society. Produced by the independent studios, the film portrays the existing relationship between the white people and other distinct communities. The film director, Justin Simien, elaborates contradictory effect of the media in the 21st century on the portrayal of race, particularly for the black people. On the other hand, Frozen River is a film directed by Courtney Hunt that revolves around a socially cognizant drama. Another distinctive feature is that Frozen River is a low budget film produced by an independent studio while Dear White People is a Hollywood film that includes a high budget as well as sophisticated equipment. As such, the movie Frozen River would not be compared to a Hollywood screenplay such as Dear White People given that the latter outsources professionals during the production and distribution stages. Importantly, it sells ownership rights to the highest bidders, thus has a high market value compared to a simple screenplay from an independent production house.

Dear White People is a film that has a storyline that revolves traditional campus setting. The film exposes a stereotypic behavior where there is a conflict of language between White students and the Black American students. As such, the film addresses substantial societal themes such as racial discrimination through a simple campus life experience. For instance, the film uses strong language to describe the black American students.

Notably, the director uses four black students to develop his context of discussion which is racial profiling. As such, he delivers to an anxious audience the impact of white privilege experienced in the campus life. A good example that best elaborates such a point develops from the various scenes displayed from the Ivy League College. On the same note, Frozen River has segments that depict racial interactions. For instance, there is a scene in the movie where Ray Eddy meets with a woman from the Indian decency. Such an intentional scene is meant to prove the social interaction in the film. As such, it evidently points to the fact that the director, Courtney Hunt, wanted to exhibit that racial connection of the world’s communities. In this view, one would agree that the two movies tend to depict similar themes though from a different approach. Subsequently, the two films prioritize such an issue differently as exhibited by character roles.

The two films (Dear White People and Frozen River) present different social classes expressing various stereotypical behaviors. For example, the director uses the wealthy class of persons to elaborate his main argument of the gap between Whites and Blacks in Dear White People. As such,an audience can connect to the author’s expression in the sense that there are the black students who cast as the victims of racial discriminations. On the same note, the director uses the college parties to elaborate that origin and existence of the white supremacy effect on the campuses. A good point to note, the director has a deeply rooted lesson for his audience with the film. However, the condensed humor in the play overshadows the moral lesson at the end of the day. Given such a realization, one would agree that the film director’s intention is to point out the objectivity of a diverse societal setting. On the contrary, the film from Frozen River portrays the challenges of struggling families in the quest to earn a living. Given a logical point of view, one would agree that the film embraces the societal challenges of both the low class and middle-class people. Additionally, it widely addresses the challenges of the immigrant societies, the Indians, struggling for better opportunities. Such a presentation effectively exhibits the gender role in a stereotypical manner.

The other distinguishing element of the film is that it assumes a complex storyline that sets a new dimension of the entire movie. For example, director Justin Simien uses the character, Samantha White, to reinvent the film’s storyline. Initially, she is an ordinary character in a typical campus environment. During screenplay, Samantha White obtains the role of a revolutionized that energizes other black American students to transforming the portrayal of the black tradition. Such a transition is different from the shift created by Courtney Hunt in the film Frozen River. Evidence that points to such reasoning is in the case that Hunt develops his character along clear thematic issues. In this instance, one would agree that the two movies tend to differ in the general plot and storyline given that each director would want to depict their innermost viewpoint of the modern society.

A good way to illustrate the distinctions between the two movies develops regarding analysis character intent and director motive. For instance, in Dear White people, Justin Simien is more concerned with presenting the societal issues that affect a particular group of minorities. His intentions revolve around pointing fingers to the impact of racial discrimination, in particular, for the African American. On the same note, he triggers a reaction from his audience given that he presents a game changing effect through humor and character symbolism. Conversely, Courtney Hunt reasons from a different viewpoint in the case that he is practical about the realities of life that affect most people. Thus, his narration technique is useful during screenplay given that he depicts heavy themes that revolve around the family institutions.

Conclusively, both the two film directors are efficient in the delivery of their themes and moral lessons for their films. Importantly, the two films are creatively developed to document about the challenges of life from a broader perspective. For instance, the film, Dear White People, is pivotal in racial discriminations experienced by the black Americans. On the other hand, the movie Frozen River addresses the complex family challenges that include drug abuse by parents, single parenting and financial constraints. A point to note, even though the films differ concerning delivery, their storyline, and plots, they tend to serve the generally intended purpose of educating the modern society. Lastly, the two movies give insight into the real life world and challenges that face ordinary people within various societal institutions. As such, they are good sources to educate the contemporary society given that they offer valuable lessons.

Works Cited

Hourihan, Chip, Heather Rae, Courtney Hunt, Melissa Leo, Misty Upham, Charlie McDermott, Michael O’Keefe, Mark Boone, Peter Golub, and Shahzad Ismaily. Frozen River. Culver City, Calif: Sony Pictures Home Entertainment, 2009.

Simien, Justin, Effie T. Brown, Julia Lebedev, Angel López, Ann Le, Lena Waithe, Leonid Lebedev, Stephanie Allain, Tyler J. Williams, Tessa Thompson, Kyle Gallner, Teyonah Parris, Brandon P. Bell, Malcolm Barrett, Brittany Curran, Justin Dobies, Marque Richardson, Dennis Haysbert, Topher Osborn, Bruton Jones, Phillip J. Bartell, Toye Adedipe, and Kathryn Bostic. Dear White People. , 2015.