• Home
  • Other
  • Does the concept of multiculturalism challenge notions of national identity and citizenship?

Does the concept of multiculturalism challenge notions of national identity and citizenship? Essay Example

  • Category:
    Other
  • Document type:
    Essay
  • Level:
    High School
  • Page:
    2
  • Words:
    1183

Rietveld, E. (2013). Debating Multiculturalism and National Idenety in Britain: Competing Frames. British Journal of Ethnicities, 14, 50–71

This article argues that strong national identity is prerequisite to a stable multicultural country. The author has examined how the tension between multiculturalism and citizenship has been understood in Britain by analysing different arguments presented by different scholars. The author has identified the causes and effects of the absence of national identity in Britain. Many countries are losing their identities as a result of globalization. Countries are becoming multicultural which is considered a challenge for national identity. The article has highlighted the implications of immigration and multiculturalism and how they are affect the beliefs of citizens. Governments fear multiculturalism caused by immigration because it challenges the originality of their cultures by bringing new cultural identities. Many countries are worried due to the increase in immigrants who corrode citizenship and nation’s history. Immigration is considered the main reason that drives multiculturalism. The article argues whether immigration laws should be made stricter in order to reduce the number of immigrants in different countries. This book is useful since it has been able to determine the connection between multiculturalism and national identity. The credibility of this book is high since it has been cited in many sources and is available in major databases. Also, the book discusses relevant real-world examples to illustrate the impacts of multiculturalism on citizenship. For instance, it has explained how multiculturalism has corroded national identity in Britain.

Bloemraad, I., Korteweg, A. and Yurdakul, G. (2008). Citizenship and Immigration: Multiculturalism, Assimilation and Challenges to the Nation-State. Annu. Rev. Social, 34: 153-179.

This journal offers credible evidence that immigration affects citizenship and the sense of belonging. Taking a serious approach to the reality of multiculturalism, the authors have offered examples to illustrate this notion. For instance, one country that has been affected by multiculturalism that has been brought about by immigration is the United States. It has drained the roots of its Anglo-Protestant that carried a great sense of assimilatory and has led to problematic integrations where the government is forced to come up with strategies to improve integration policies. This paper is useful because it correlates the issues of multiculturalism and national identity with immigration. Nevertheless, it has put more emphasis on ethnic and civic citizenship more than on multiculturalism. The authors could have covered more grounds on the challenges caused by multiculturalism on national identity and citizenship. This journal has high credibility because it offers real world examples to illustrate the challenges different country face due to multiculturalism and assimilation. Going beyond the context, the credibility of the paper can also be reflected from the efforts of the authors to offer methodological and theoretical evidence of the relationship between multiculturalism and national identity.

Johnson, K. R. and Hing, B. O. (2005). National Identity in a Multicultural Nation: The Challenge of Immigration Law and Immigrants. Michigan Law Review, 6(103), p. 1380-99.

This article is based on the challenges of globalization to national identity in the United States. The authors fear that multiculturalism will corrode the American identity due to the concept of immigration. Multiculturalism in the United States could disintegrate the national identity and destroy the concept of citizenship. For instance, Yugoslavia has been divided due to increase in globalization which has enabled the movement of people outside and inside the country. The authors report that the United States lost its national identity in the twentieth century due to its favourable immigration policies. The authors have expressed fear about high levels of immigration in the country on the American way of living. Immigration therefore affects the American identity since the country has seen large number of immigrants coming from different countries especially Mexico. This article is useful in the discussion of multiculturalism and national identity since it offers real-life evidence of how immigration impacts national identity. Therefore, having a plan of action that can minimize immigration would reduce multiculturalism and eventually boost national identity. This article is a credible source since the arguments presented by the authors build on other findings found in other studies.

Chin, J.L (2004). Cultural competence in a multicultural society. Journal of Quality and Participation, 27(4), 19-21.

This article studies the different ways people understand the knowledge of multiculturalism and citizenship and changes that have been brought about by multicultural influx. Throughout the article, the author demonstrates the effects of multi-cultural groups on the society today. Their impacts range from policy reforms, technological integration as well as social interactions. One reason why this article differentiates itself from the rest is its ability to present a future possible look of the effect that multiculturalism will have on the society which include the change in demographics and political agendas. From the analysis presented in the article, the author predicts a multicultural and highly technological society that could affect the way of life. He has made a number of recommendations to assist policy makers in reducing the impacts of multiculturalism on national identity. Also, he has noted that it is important for people to accept these changes and admit to inclusion. This article is credible since the author has presented his arguments with minimal prejudice by including dissenting opinions of other scholars. It has also presented different arguments using examples and information is presented professionally and in a polished manner.

Mitchell, K. (2004). Geographies of identity: Multiculturalism unplugged. Progress in Human Geography 28(5), 641–651.

The authors in the article attempt to determine the relationship between multiculturalism and self-identity. The main aim of the article is to explain the on-going process of multiculturalism and how it influences politics and national identity. The authors have done a good job at illustrating that multiculturalism is brought about by the diverse groups entering and leaving a country. They give a clear indication of how the future will look like with the open movement of people from one country to another due to globalization. The article has made a point that countries face a huge challenge of managing to integrate ethnically diverse groups that enter their borders. Cultural assimilation is a terminology that is an integral part of different countries today that limits the ability to practice national identity. The article is useful since it has presented relevant information that can be used by future sociologists to determine the progression in national identity in a multicultured environment. The article is credible since it has been written for relevant audience at an easy readable level and the content is still relevant today.

References

Bloemraad, I., Korteweg, A. and Yurdakul, G. (2008). Citizenship and Immigration: Multiculturalism, Assimilation and Challenges to the Nation-State. Annu. Rev. Social, 34: 153-179.

Chin, J.L (2004). Cultural competence in a multicultural society. Journal of Quality and Participation, 27(4): 19-21.

Johnson, K. R. and Hing, B. O. (2005). National Identity in a Multicultural Nation: The Challenge of Immigration Law and Immigrants. Michigan Law Review, 6(103): 1380-99.

Mitchell, K. (2004). Geographies of identity: Multiculturalism unplugged. Progress in Human Geography 28(5): 641–651.

Rietveld, E. (2013). Debating Multiculturalism and National Idenety in Britain: Competing Frames. British Journal of Ethnicities, 14: 50–71.

Save Your Time for
More Important Things
Let us write or edit the article on your topic